Winter Pool Cover vs Mesh Safety Cover: Which Do You Need?

|ShadeMart
Winter Pool Cover vs Mesh Safety Cover: Which Do You Need?

Both keep leaves out over the off-season, but they work very differently and cost very different amounts. Here is how to choose.

Solid winter cover (tarp)

  • How it works: a solid polyethylene tarp held down by a cable and winch (above ground) or water bags and weights (inground).
  • Good for: keeping debris and sunlight out so the water stays cleaner for opening day.
  • Keep in mind: rain and snowmelt collect on top and need to be pumped off. It is not a walk-on barrier.
  • Price: from about $54 for a 15 ft round pool.

Shop round, oval or rectangle inground winter covers.

Mesh safety cover

  • How it works: a strapped polypropylene mesh stretched tight with springs to brass anchors set in the deck.
  • Good for: inground pools where you want a strong, anchored barrier over the water and less maintenance; rain drains through the mesh.
  • Keep in mind: it needs anchors drilled into the deck, and fine particles can pass through the mesh.
  • Price: from about $520 for a 16 x 32 ft pool with a step.

Shop 16x32 with step, 20x40 with step or covers without a step.

Quick guide

Winter tarp Mesh safety
Pool type Above ground or inground Inground
Install Cable/winch or water bags Deck anchors and springs
Rain and snowmelt Collects on top Drains through
Cost Lower Higher

Ready to measure? See how to measure for a winter pool cover.